Call Us Now — (802) 773-3000
Get a Quote

We represent several national and regional carriers:

Our Goal

Our goal is to be the best insurance
agency possible for each of our clients

Hull Maynard Hersey Insurance has deep roots in Rutland and Woodstock, Vermont. However, we serve clients throughout the region in New Hampshire, New York, Massachusetts, and Maine as well.
Customer Service

Committed to Customer Service

While many insurance providers would have you spending hours on hold just to connect with a representative at a call center, our locally owned company remains committed to personalized customer service.
Insurance Shield Dark

Wide Range of Carriers

As independent insurance agents, and with our access to a wider range of carriers, you have more room to be selective about your coverage — that means optimal benefits for the most competitive price.
Agents

Local Agents

We continue to upgrade our technologies and offer modern, automated solutions for our clients, our local agents are always available to take your call, answer your questions, and help you select the insurance coverage for your needs.
Our Mission

Our Mission Is To Provide Dedicated Customer Service

Every insurance agency sells for reputable carriers. The difference comes down to customer service. And that’s what we emphasize the most in our company.

We work for our clients, which means we’re here to translate complex policy jargon into simple language you can understand, and to answer any questions you might have. We’ll also take the time to truly understand your needs and provide you with options. Our mission is to provide the dedicated customer service you need to feel comfortable and confident purchasing any type of insurance you might need.

Need help finding insurance that’s right for your needs? Our friendly insurance agents are ready to help you explore your insurance options.

Meet The Team
drone shot house
Customer satisfaction is our number one priority. We want to make sure you're happy with the service we provide and that's why we always go above and beyond to ensure that your needs are met.
History

Our History

Before Hull Maynard Hersey Insurance, there was the Hull Maynard Agency, which was founded by Hull Maynard in 1978. However, Hull had previously been a partner at the Jones-Maynard Agency since 1962. Following in the family footsteps, Jill Maynard Nolan joined her father in 1991, and the company subsequently merged with Hersey Insurance Services, bringing on Scott W. Hersey as a partner.

In 2022, after many successful years together, Scott fully retired from the company. Today, Jill Maynard Nolan solely manages Hull Maynard Hersey Insurance Services. With a passion for customer service and a deep understanding of the ever-changing insurance landscape, you can count on Jill and her team of local agents for all of your insurance needs.

insurance agency in rutland vermont
What We Offer

Insurance Programs

We represent national and regional carriers to provide a wide range of insurance lines that fit into your lifestyle. Whether you own a business, are an adventuring weekend warrior, or run a small farm, we can help you build comprehensive coverage with the right policies at the right price.

Latest Articles

Our Blog
Our team of experts provides the resources you need to make an informed decision and find the right policy.
How much is life insurance per month​?

How much is life insurance per month​?

On April 15, 2025
By amit
Life insurance is one of the most essential financial tools for protecting your family’s future and ensuring long-term stability. Whether you’re planning for your children’s education, covering outstanding debts like a mortgage, or preparing for unforeseen events, life insurance offers a reliable safety net. It guarantees that your loved ones will be financially supported in […]
Are life insurance annuity proceeds taxable

Are life insurance annuity proceeds taxable?

On March 22, 2025
By Jill Maynard-Nolan
Annuities are financial instruments designed to provide a stable income stream, making them a popular choice for retirement planning. However, a key consideration when investing in annuities is understanding their tax treatment. A common question among policyholders is: Are life insurance annuity proceeds taxable? The answer depends on various factors, including the type of annuity, […]
When does gap insurance not pay

When does gap insurance not pay?

On March 21, 2025
By Jill Maynard-Nolan
Gap insurance, or Guaranteed Asset Protection insurance, is a specialized form of coverage that helps protect you from financial loss if your vehicle is totaled or stolen. It covers the “gap” between the actual cash value (ACV) of your car, which is typically lower due to depreciation, and the remaining balance on your loan or […]
Want to learn more?
Visit Our Blog
Let’s Get Started

We Make It Easy For You To Get Insured

Get a Free Quote

Get a Free Quote

When you request a quote for any insurance policy through us, we can provide a variety of options from different carriers, so you get the best possible rate on your coverage.
OR
Chat an Agent

Call an Agent

Whether you just prefer a friendly voice or need more information, we are here to help individuals and businesses with personal and commercial insurance solutions.
Rutland Office
(802) 773-3000
Woodstock Office
(802) 457-4143
Send us an email:
info@hmhvt.com
Scroll Down